obvious casting ruins too many tv show mysteries
Sitting down one evening — well in this case, lying down — to watch myself an episode of CSI:NY.
(Mini-review: Not a great show, by far the weakest of the CSI mega-conglomerate, but eh? it’s something to do on a Wednesday night before waking my wife up with my snoring.)
So, on this particular evening, Gary Sinise — don’t know his character’s name, don’t feel a need to learn it, it ain’t needed… ever — is investigating the discovery of a body found half-eaten in a tiger-pen.
[side-note] Do CSI techs ever investigate plain-old gang-related shootings? Muggings? Anything mundane at all?! Damn — Sherlock Holmes didn’t have plots this byzantine! [end side-note]
Anyways, I’m watching the show and less than ten minutes into the episode Gary Sinise stops a passing landscaper to ask him simple question, gets a simple answer, and then the landscaper disappears… supposedly never to be seen again.
(Yes, I know, they aren’t going to show things that aren’t important to the plot, but still, good shows will leave a couple of blind alleys to lead the viewers astray.)
But — immediately — I knew:
“He did it.”
How did I know?
Because I recognised the actor.
I don’t know his name and couldn’t name too many shows he had appeared on (well, he was on Six Feet Under as Ruth Fisher’s friend from the flower shop). But he is one of those horde of actors that make a living playing small guest roles on TV shows. And I recognise these people. Their faces are memorable. They are good actors. But recognisable.
And they are not hired — for the most part — for unimportant roles.
So, I spend the rest of the episode, impatiently waiting for Gary Sinise and the rest of his merry band of CSI Techs/Bosses-Of-Everyone-Else-With-A-Badge to finally figure out that he did it.
These episodes drive me absolutely over-the-edge, pass Tom Cruise along the road, crazy.
Hire some freaking unknown actors for the freaking murderers, people! Make it a freaking mystery!
(Crap. Just received a fine for over-use of the word “freaking”.)
This isn’t a constant problem. Some shows do, from time to time, hire recognisable actors for “blind alley parts”. Some shows will write the mystery so that having recognised these actors doesn’t effect the actual detective work involved (e.g. they suspect that someone committed a murder but can’t figure out how). And some shows will be kind and just use unknown actors for the whole guest cast (bless them).
I know this isn’t a big problem. But it can be really annoying. (I’m looking at you, Law & Order.)
Fix it. For the good of humanity. I implore you.
(And hey — the struggling actors out there will love you.)
